The Fitness Freak
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Exercise
    • Cardio Training
    • Strength Training
    • Pilates
    • Yoga
  • Fitness
    • Fitness Gadgets
    • Health Trackers
  • Health
    • Personal Care
    • Hair & Body Care
    • Skin Care
    • Vitamins
    • Protein
  • Nutrition
    • Diet
  • Lifestyle
  • Home
  • Exercise
    • Cardio Training
    • Strength Training
    • Pilates
    • Yoga
  • Fitness
    • Fitness Gadgets
    • Health Trackers
  • Health
    • Personal Care
    • Hair & Body Care
    • Skin Care
    • Vitamins
    • Protein
  • Nutrition
    • Diet
  • Lifestyle
The Fitness Freak
No Result
View All Result
Home Health

Vitamin supplements: more harm than help?

thefitnessfreak by thefitnessfreak
October 11, 2011
in Health, Vitamins
0 0
0
Vitamin supplements: more harm than help?
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


A study published yesterday in the Archives of Internal Medicine investigated the link between taking dietary supplements and an increased risk of death in older women.

Associate Professor Ian Chapman from the University of Adelaide explains the methodology and results of the study.

This article examines the Iowa Women’s Health Study, which began in 1986, and examines death or death rates through 2008.

The average follow-up period was 19 years for each person. Subjects were older postmenopausal women with an average age of 61 at the start of the study.

I don’t know if this is a great article because there are so many variables that the authors corrected for: there were clear differences between the women who took the supplements and those who didn’t initially.

Women who took the supplements were more likely to be non-smokers; they were twice as likely to take hormone replacement therapy (HRT); they had higher levels of education and lower body mass index; and they were more physically active.

Moreover, they were different for each measure of food intake reported in the article.

The authors attempted to correct for these differences with their analyzes and found some effects of the supplements.

But I can’t find the absolute death rate in the paper in either of the two groups before the authors started their corrections. And you should be wary when people make corrections for a variety of variables.

These are statistical corrections and there are ways to make them, but they don’t take into account the underlying factors.

Women who are not feeling well, for example, can start taking multivitamins or minerals. And they could die because they weren’t well, not because of the multi-vitamins or the minerals.

This type of factor is not taken into account in these multivariate analyses.

The link with iron supplements and mortality is the strongest. Why would older women take iron supplements?

I assume the women were taking iron supplements because they were iron deficient, which may be related to bleeding. It is the most common cause of iron deficiency and anemia.

In a postmenopausal woman, this is likely due to gastrointestinal bleeding or some postmenopausal uterine bleeding. Now neither of these is good and both could reflect a negative result anyway.

In fact, the supplements could address the thing that causes these women to have an increased death rate.

Alternatively, iron can be given non-specifically for anemia without the women necessarily being iron deficient.

High body iron stores have been associated with increased rates of cardiovascular events in some studies. The link between increased mortality and iron supplementation appears to be quite strong in the analyses. Iron appears to be associated with an increased death rate, while calcium is linked to a reduced death rate.

These are two of the strongest conclusions of the article.

What other studies have concluded about taking supplements?

There have been a number of such studies – population-based prospective cross-sectional studies rather than randomized controlled trials.

Most of them show no great mortality or welfare benefit from taking minerals or multivitamins in the absence of a well-defined deficiency syndrome.

Meta-analyses have recently suggested that vitamin D supplements for older people might help them live a bit longer, but there really isn’t a whole lot of evidence.

And, in some circumstances, there is even evidence of harm. Overall, there may be more evidence for harm than good, especially if certain supplements are taken in large amounts.

In particular, some antioxidants, such as vitamins E and A, can cause harm if taken in excess.

Why is it so difficult to get a clear picture of vitamin and mineral supplements?

The problem with all of these studies is that they are not strictly speaking randomized controlled trials.

That’s because the latter are really hard to do: different people in the control group will go off and take multi-vitamins and minerals on the side – how do you control that?

And you have to do a study for a number of years. This study had an average follow-up of 19 years in nearly 40,000 women. Ideally, we should take a group of people and randomly divide them into groups that may or may not contain minerals and vitamins, and then follow them to see what happens.

It would be extremely difficult to conduct such a large study for such a long time in a randomized, controlled fashion.

So we have studies like this one that use varied data that have to be adjusted, and the authors end up saying, when we’ve made all these adjustments, we end up with this result.

What should we take away from this study?

The proof of the study is that you don’t live longer taking multi-vitamins and minerals, with the possible exception of calcium.

Whether or not there is harm I think is another matter and I wouldn’t rely too much on this document to draw evidence from it.

The article and editorial associated with this study do not support the use of supplements in healthy people who have no known impairments and who are not taking medications or have a disease that could cause it. And I wouldn’t recommend them either.

Related Posts

Vitamin C vs. Retinol: Which One Should You Use for Your Skin?
Health

Vitamin C vs. Retinol: Which One Should You Use for Your Skin?

February 7, 2023
Peptide-Infused Skincare Products to Add to Your Routine
Health

Peptide-Infused Skincare Products to Add to Your Routine

February 6, 2023
The Science Behind Vitamin C's Anti-Aging Properties for the Skin
Health

The Science Behind Vitamin C’s Anti-Aging Properties for the Skin

February 3, 2023
Amazing benefits of eating kokum fruit
Health

Amazing benefits of eating kokum fruit

February 2, 2023
Bhujangasana benefits and steps
Health

Bhujangasana benefits and steps

February 2, 2023
Benefits of brahmi oil for hair
Hair & Body Care

Benefits of brahmi oil for hair

February 2, 2023
Next Post
Vitamins: myths, facts, use and misuse

Vitamins: myths, facts, use and misuse

POPULAR NEWS

Learn the Ins and Outs of Pickleball from 2 of Its Best Players

Learn the Ins and Outs of Pickleball from 2 of Its Best Players

January 11, 2023
How many Australians are going hungry? We don't know for sure, and that's a big part of the problem

How many Australians are going hungry? We don’t know for sure, and that’s a big part of the problem

December 12, 2022
Migraine sufferers have treatment choices – a neurologist explains options beyond just pain medication

Migraine sufferers have treatment choices – a neurologist explains options beyond just pain medication

July 11, 2022
Tips & Tricks to Unleash Your Inner Grillmaster

Tips & Tricks to Unleash Your Inner Grillmaster

September 10, 2021
Causes and symptoms of thyroid hair loss

Causes and symptoms of thyroid hair loss

December 27, 2022

The Fitness Freak

Are you ready to change from within? Welcome to The Fitness Freak! The goal of The Fitness Freak is to provide you with the best info about exercise, fitness, health, nutrition and wellness to give you a healthy lifestyle. We hope that you get the most value from our website.

Categories

  • Cardio Training
  • Diet
  • Exercise
  • Fitness
  • Fitness Gadgets
  • Hair & Body Care
  • Health
  • Health Trackers
  • Lifestyle
  • Nutrition
  • Personal Care
  • Pilates
  • Protein
  • Skin Care
  • Strength Training
  • Vitamins
  • Yoga

Recent Posts

  • George Karlaftis Has Been Prepped for His Super Bowl Moment
  • Vitamin C vs. Retinol: Which One Should You Use for Your Skin?
  • Iron Rich Foods – 8 Foods to Add to Your Iron Diet
  • Gain Super Bowl Speed with These Sprint Drills
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

Copyright © 2022 Thefitnessfreak.co | All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Exercise
    • Cardio Training
    • Strength Training
    • Pilates
    • Yoga
  • Fitness
    • Fitness Gadgets
    • Health Trackers
  • Health
    • Personal Care
    • Hair & Body Care
    • Skin Care
    • Vitamins
    • Protein
  • Nutrition
    • Diet
  • Lifestyle

Copyright © 2022 Thefitnessfreak.co | All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In